Event starts in:
61 : 04 : 56 : 37
days hours minutes seconds
Award Overview

Best Published Research Paper Award

The Best Published Research Paper Award recognizes exemplary original research published between January 1st, 2025 and June 30th, 2026 by a neurosurgeon or neurosurgery resident trainee of Pakistan. Only original articles published in peer-reviewed, indexed journals are eligible for consideration. Conferred at the 39th Pakistan Society of Neurosurgery Annual Conference, the award is instituted to cultivate and reinforce a robust culture of clinician-scientist engagement, academic rigor, and scholarly excellence within the neurosurgical fraternity. It seeks to honor research that demonstrates methodological robustness, intellectual originality, and substantive clinical relevance, with particular resonance to the healthcare landscape and neurosurgical needs of Pakistan.

Eligibility Criteria

Publication Timeline
  • Published between January 1st, 2025 – June 30th, 2026
Applicant Requirements
  • Working at the institution of published study during the study time
  • First author in the study
  • Resident trainee OR Consultant Neurosurgeon of Pakistan
  • Medical students are NOT eligible
Journal & Article Type
  • Peer-reviewed, national or international journal
  • Original article types: RCT, quasi-experimental, cohort, case-control, cross-sectional, or large case series
  • NOT eligible: Systematic reviews, meta-analyses, clinical audits, case reports, letters, editorials
Study Location
  • Conducted within Pakistani institutions/hospitals
  • Multicenter studies involving foreign institutions are eligible

Scoring Criteria (Total = 100 Marks)

Domain 1
50

Scientific Quality & Methodology

Assessed by: Chief Editor of a PubMed-indexed Pakistani journal Evaluation Domains:
  • Study design appropriateness
  • Sample size & power
  • Statistical analysis
  • Bias & confounding control
  • Data integrity & ethics
  • Conclusion strength
Domain 2
30

Originality & Innovation

Assessed by: Three senior neurosurgeons (independent reviewers) Evaluation Domains:
  • Research question novelty
  • Surgical/methodological innovation
  • New knowledge contribution
  • Literature distinction
Domain 3
20

Clinical Relevance & Pakistan Impact

Assessed by: Community medicine expert & Pakistani neurosurgeon Evaluation Domains:
  • Pakistani healthcare applicability
  • Local disease burden relevance
  • Clinical practice influence
  • Resource-constrained feasibility

Scoring Process

  • Each domain is scored independently by assigned evaluator(s)
  • Final score is the sum of all three components out of 100
  • In case of a tie, higher methodology score takes precedence
Important Information

The award does not incorporate quantitative metrics such as citation counts, h-index, or platform-based indicators (e.g., ResearchGate or similar indices) into the scoring system. These measures are often time-dependent, variable across platforms, and may not accurately reflect the true scientific quality or clinical value of recently published work. Instead, the evaluation focuses on methodological rigor, originality, and meaningful clinical impact, ensuring a fair and merit-based assessment of all submissions.

Submission Form